Golf Course Review
Fishers Island, NY
18 holesPar 72premium / private
#11 in Americacommunity rating
Fishers Island Club is located on Fishers Island, New York, featuring 18 holes at par 72. This Seth Raynor design sits on a remote island setting off Connecticut, offering ocean views on nearly every hole. The course presents a true pilgrimage for golfers seeking a distinctive coastal experience.
The club's premium positioning reflects its exclusivity and geography. On First Loop, Fishers Island Club ranks #11 nationally and #4 in New York, making it a highly regarded destination tracked alongside thousands of other courses across the country.
Seth Raynor gem on a remote island off Connecticut. Ocean views on nearly every hole — a true pilgrimage.
Fishers Island Club is rated 9.5/10 by real golfers on First Loop. Ratings are based on head-to-head Elo comparisons — no editorial bias.
Fishers Island Club is a golf course located in Fishers Island, New York. It is a 18-hole, par 72 course.
Fishers Island Club is ranked #11 in America by the First Loop community. Rankings are determined by Elo head-to-head comparisons from verified golfers, not magazine editors.
Fishers Island Club is one of the highest-rated golf courses nationally — a must-play according to the First Loop community.
Fishers Island Club is categorized as premium / private ($$) based on First Loop community data.
Log your round on First Loop after playing Fishers Island Club in Fishers Island, New York. Rate it head-to-head against other courses you've played to contribute to the community rankings.
Compare New York Rankings
Southampton, NY
Riverhead, NY
Southampton, NY
Mamaroneck, NY
Southampton, NY
Rankings updated May 2026