Golf Course Review
Shelter Island, NY
18 holesPar 72
#263 in New Yorkcommunity rating
Gardiner's Bay Country Club is an 18-hole, par 72 course located in Shelter Island, New York. The club offers golfers a chance to play on Long Island's North Fork, an area known for its natural beauty and coastal character. Members and guests can expect a full golfing experience in this distinctive setting.
The course is tracked on First Loop alongside thousands of other courses across the country, making it easy to discover, review, and share your round with fellow golfers.
Gardiner's Bay Country Club is rated 7.4/10 by real golfers on First Loop. Ratings are based on head-to-head Elo comparisons — no editorial bias.
Gardiner's Bay Country Club is a golf course located in Shelter Island, New York. It is a 18-hole, par 72 course.
Gardiner's Bay Country Club is ranked #263 among golf courses in New York on First Loop.
Gardiner's Bay Country Club receives solid community reviews. Most golfers who have played it would recommend it to others in New York.
Log your round on First Loop after playing Gardiner's Bay Country Club in Shelter Island, New York. Rate it head-to-head against other courses you've played to contribute to the community rankings.
Compare New York Rankings
Southampton, NY
Riverhead, NY
Southampton, NY
Fishers Island, NY
Mamaroneck, NY
Rankings updated May 2026